Skip to content
← All sections

Section 14

Lord, Liar, Lunatic, Legend

A man who claimed what Jesus claimed was either Lord, liar, lunatic, or his claim was a later legend. The "great teacher" option is foreclosed.

Liar: requires a motive. The standard motives (money, power, sex, fame) do not match Jesus’s life pattern. Liars abandon the lie under pressure. Jesus did not.

Lunatic: his teaching is not the teaching of a clinically delusional man. Readers outside Christianity have ranked it among the highest. Gandhi drew directly on the Sermon on the Mount; the Jewish historian Joseph Klausner called Jesus’s ethical teaching one of the choicest possessions of the Hebrew tradition, while rejecting his Messianic claim.

Legend: the claims are not late. The 1 Cor 15 creed within 5 years. Pliny on Christians "singing hymns to Christ as to a god" within 80 years. Hurtado and Bauckham documented worship of Jesus as divine within years.

That leaves Lord.

A man who was merely a man and said the sort of things Jesus said would not be a great moral teacher. He would either be a lunatic, on the level with the man who says he is a poached egg, or else he would be the Devil of Hell.

C. S. Lewis, Mere Christianity, 1952, pp. 54 to 55.

By the numbers

Options
Lord, Liar, Lunatic, Legend
Earliest creed
within 5 years
Hurtado on early devotion
binitarian within years

Strongest counter position

A skeptic can hold a "complex" position: a charismatic teacher whose claims were exaggerated by the early church. Engaged in section 5 and section 11.

What this does not prove

The trilemma works as a clarifying frame, ruling out the popular middle ground. It does not by itself prove Lord; the case rests on the historical claims and the resurrection.

Citations

  • C. S. Lewis, Mere Christianity, 1952.
  • 1 Corinthians 15:3 to 8.
  • Philippians 2:6 to 11.
  • Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96.
  • Larry Hurtado, Lord Jesus Christ, 2003.
  • Joseph Klausner, Jesus of Nazareth, 1925.

Goes deeper

Cite this section

APA 7
Reyhe, K. (2026). Lord, Liar, Lunatic, Legend. Section of Christianity True. https://christistrue.org/en/sections/trilemma/
MLA 9
Reyhe, Konrad. “Lord, Liar, Lunatic, Legend.” Section of Christianity True, 2026, https://christistrue.org/en/sections/trilemma/.
Chicago
Reyhe, Konrad. 2026. “Lord, Liar, Lunatic, Legend.” Section of Christianity True. https://christistrue.org/en/sections/trilemma/.

Keyboard: k prev j next